When Beggars Can’t Be Choosers: Week 11
Wednesday, November 12th, 2008We haven’t done this in a couple weeks despite suggesting we’d make it a weekly feature. And it’s a bit premature, but here are some ideal replacements for injured starters in the oncoming week of fantasy football. Actually, it isn’t premature at all as there is a game tomorrow night. That game might not exist to us because it’s on NFL Network, but it exists to everyone else apparently, so we might as well knock this out of the way.
1) Antonio Pittman
It stands to reason that you have no idea who this is unless you live in Ohio or St. Louis, but he is Stephen Jackson’s backup running back and looks to see the majority of carries out of the backfield. He didn’t exactly set the world on fire against the Jets, but they have the Niners this weekend. And the Niners don’t have anywhere near the run stopper of Kris Jenkins. After watching him run for three years at Ohio State, trust me, this kid can run given modestly favorable circumstances.
2) BenJarvus Green-Ellis
I kind of can’t stand this guy because he represents the overt and unapologetic random nature of modern day NFL running backs. At this point, running backs are to the NFL what peripheral actors are to television sitcoms: utterly replaceable. We wish him all the best but what he means for the league is pretty infuriating from a fantasy perspective. But he will get the majority of touches because Bill Belichick merely tolerates Kevin Faulk, he doesn’t actually like him. If Ellis hasn’t already been acquired in your league (and we would like to join your league if that is the case) you would be wise to do so post-haste.

Switching Becky's on Roseanne had no impact on the ratings, just like switching running backs rarely effects a game's outcome.
3) Cedric Benson
You won’t believe me when I say he actually looks serviceable for the Bengals, so let me just offer some numbers and wild speculation as to what those numbers mean: In his most recent game against the Jags he rushed for 104 yards and a touchdown on 24 carries. The most vital part of that stat line for fantasy? The 24 carries, as it looks like they are veering more towards him than the fumble prone Chris Perry, not to mention that the game against the Jags was the first they won all season. They are playing the Eagles who have upped their run defense from years past (though Jacobs still diced them up on Sunday night), but the Bengals are coming off a bye week. We aren’t guaranteeing a 100 yard, two TD game, but we are pretty certain he will get 70% of the carries against an over-confident Eagles team.
4) Dominick Rhodes
The Colts have one of the worst running offenses in the league and Addai, though he will play, still looked pretty hampered in the Steelers. We believe that Rhodes is still the inferior back, but if they are splitting carries about evenly (as they appeared to be doing against Pittsburgh), they are going to try and rest their top-tier player and throw Rhodes out their more frequently against the lowly Texans, whose defense is reminiscent of the Dick Vermeil Chiefs who started onside kicking midway through the third quarter in the playoffs a few years ago.
5) Ledell Betts
Clinton Portis is questionable (he probably wouldn’t play if they were going tomorrow night), so picking up Betts and waiting out the final verdict probably isn’t the worst strategy. If Portis does play, fine, just put him on the bench and play whoever you were going to in lieu of the backup. If he doesn’t, then you have a running back who’ll get over 60% of the carries against a banged up (albeit determined) Dallas defense. There is no downside to the proposition unless you have some sort of sentimental attachment to your bench players you’re never going to start in the first place.
Back later with something.





